Oops. Forgot to answer Casa Pearl about this. We stayed at Mitchell's Sandcastles on Sanibel Island. A steal at twice the price.
I loved the environment of Sanibel for our little four day stay. It was very sedate and calm and restful - just the thing I needed after that LONG winter break with the kids at home and then the push to get all of the end of the year payroll stuff finished.
Sometimes I like quiet and sedate. Other times I like to be somewhere with constant action, like Las Vegas. I'm lucky that my husband likes both of those types of vacations, too.